Time, the ever baffling one directional mystery. A lot of it has been spent between the members of slub on ways to synchronise multiple machines to share a simple beat, sometimes attempting industrial strength solutions but somehow the longest standing approach we always come back to for our various ad-hoc software remains to be a single osc message. This is the kind of thing that seems to normally involve stressed pre-performance hacking, so after having to rewriting it for temporal recursion I thought I should get it down here for future reference!
The message is called “/sync” and contains two floating point values, the first the number of beats in a “bar” (which is legacy, we don’t use this now) and then the current beats per minute. The time the message is sent is considered to be the start of the beat. A sync message comes into my system via a daemon called syncup. All this really does is attach a timestamp to the sync message recording what the local time on my machine was when it arrived, and sends it on to fluxus. Shared timestamps would be better, but don’t make any sense without a shared clock, and they seem fragile to our demands. The daemon polls on a fairly tight loop (100ms) and the resulting timestamp seems accurate enough for our ears (fluxus runs on the frame refresh rate which is too variable for this job).
So now we have a new sync message which includes a timestamp for the beat start. The first thing the system does is to assume this is in the past, and that the current time has already moved ahead. There are 3 points of time involved:
From the sync time (in the past, on the left) and the bpm we can calculate the beat times into the future. We have a “logical time” which is initialised with the current time from the system clock, a safety margin added, and then gets “snapped” to the nearest beat. The safety margin is needed as the synth graph build and play messages coming from fluxus need to be early enough to get scheduled by fluxa’s synth engine to play with sample accuracy.
The beat snapping has to be able to move back in time as well as forwards, for tiny adjustments from the sync messages (as they never come in exactly when they are expected) otherwise we skip beats. The algorithm to do this is as follows:
(define (snap-time-to-sync time) (+ time (calc-offset time last-sync-time (* (/ 1 bpm) 60)))) (define (calc-offset time-now sync-time beat-dur) ;; find the difference in terms of tempo (let* ((diff (/ (- sync-time time-now) beat-dur)) ;; get the fractional remainder (doesn't matter how ;; far in the past or future the synctime is) (fract (- diff (floor diff)))) ;; do the snapping (if (< fract 0.5) ;; need to jump forwards - convert back into seconds (* fract beat-dur) ;; the beat is behind us, so go backwards (- (* (- 1 fract) beat-dur)))))
The last thing that is needed is a global sync offset, which I add at the start of the process, to the incoming message timestamps – this has to be tuned by ear, and accounts for the fact that the latency between the synth playing a note and the speakers moving air seems to vary between machines dependent on many uncertain factors – sound card parameters, battery vs ac power, sound system setup, colour of your backdrop etc.
Other than this we tend to keep the networking tech to a minimum and use our ears and scribbled drawn scores (sometimes made from stones) to share any other musical data.
2 thoughts on “Making time”
Interessting! So if I got that right all the clients just listen to the sync message, which will be received once per beat, and the sync message determines when the next beat will occur, due to the BPM, the timestamp and various offsets?
What happens if a OSC message is dropped due to poor network conditions?
In theory you only need to send the osc message when the bpm changes – as (calc-offset) will work whenever the last sync-time was, so dropped messages are no problem.
In practice I believe sometimes /sync messages are sent every beat, other times every 8 beats or so, depending on the limitations of the other bits and pieces involved with a slub gig 🙂